HOPE X: Ethical Questions and Best Practices for Service Providers in the Post-Snowden Era

Liveblogged at HOPE X.
Nicholas Merrill, Calyx Internet Access, @nickcalyx
Ladar Levison, Lavabit
Declan McCullagh, @declanm

FBI Agents asked Ladar to turn over his SSL key. This meant 1. that the SSL key belonged to the provider, not the user; 2. that they would need to decrypt everyone's communication to find what they wee looking for; 3. that was beyond what he felt he could morally do. It was even worse, that he was prevented from telling anyone about the request.
Question: Could you talk to an attorney?
Ladar: Because the request was tied to criminal investigation, I was able to consult an attorney. If it's a classified warrant you need permission from the FBI before contacting a lawyer. He wanted to talk to others to get more information about these types of requests, but he couldn't.
Question: If you start a big company. What do you do when a government agency asks to tap your metadata, you appeal and you lose?
Nick: Startups need to be aware of this, and build a system in which you cannot provide data. If you create a situation in which only the end users have the keys, then the service providers have nothing to hand over.
Question: What about a more nefarious request, like putting malware on users?
Nick: CALEA compels service providers to give government agencies access to telephone calls and internet traffic, under civil or criminal penalties. One legal hack is to make sure that the service provider and the software developer are separate legal entities. His response, though, would probably be to call the ACLU.
Question: Should ethical companies use a warrant canary in their terms of service?
Ladar: This came up in his case. He asked if he could remove marketing claims that his service was "secure."
Nick: Warrant canaries haven't been tested, it could work, but I wouldn't want to be the one to try. What if you made the passphrase to your key an incriminating statement?
Question: Is there a continuum of ethics when it comes to companies giving you free products in order to collect data on you?
Ladar: Yes, that's why things like the EFF Scorecard are so helpful.
Nick: The whole business model of targeted advertising has to be thrown out the window if you want to be serious about privacy. We need to move back to the fee for service model.
Nick is still fighting a gag order that was issued 10 years ago, in 2004. He's had help from the ACLU and the Yale Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic.
Every time someone has fought an NSL letter all the way to the top, the FBI has retracted the NSL.
Ladar: How long is it ethical to keep the subject of an investigation secret.
Nick: There needs to be a statutory limit. Indefinite gag orders have been found unconstitutional repeatedly.
Question and Answer
Q: I moved my ISP server to Iceland. At what point am I subject to CALEA?
Ladar: Anyone who uses the telephone lines.
Q: Is being formed as an LLC a problem? Is there a best corporate entity?
Ladar: An LLC is not allowed to appear in court pro se. He was given 4 days to find an attorney in a jurisdiction 1000 miles from his home. Their advice was "give them what they want or be prepared to go to jail." He points out that he didn't really need a lawyer for those options.
Q: An ISP operator asks whether a declaratory judgement could be used by an ISP to challenge NSLs proactively.
Marsha Hoffman: Because you wouldn't have standing, you couldn't take a hypothetical to court.
Ladar: There's no guidebook for ethics for ISPs, and because of gag orders, you have to figure it out on your own, in a vacuum.
Q: If the FBI forces you to advertise insecure services as "secure," doesn't that subject you to prosecution by the FTC?
Ladar: Yes, the FTC and FBI have conflicting interests, but the better-funded FBI wins.
Nick: CALEA was designed for phone companies. It has expanded in scope without public scrutiny.
Ladar: When CALEA was passed, congress debated and decided not to apply it to email.
Q: How do you prevent creating a honeypot for government agencies looking for data?
Nick: Decentralization is key. Tor is working on a Tor-based instant messaging service.
Comment: The law should have to go to users, not service providers to get data on users.
Ladar: One problem is that technology is convenient. That convenience comes at the price of some privacy. But we're giving up far more than we need to. Ladar is working to fix that for email with Dark Mail.
Internetsurveillancelawtechnology solutions