"How can we strengthen the Internet for free expression and innovation?" is the theme of the most recent Knight News Challenge, which received 704 submissions, supported 54 entries through a refinement process, and is announcing the winners today. Previous challenges have focused on health data, Open Government, Mobile News, Networks, and much more. Sands Fish and I were there to liveblog the announcement of grantees.
Why would the Knight Foundation focus on a free Internet, and why should it matter to the world of news? Alberto Ibarguen gets on stage to explain Knight's thinking behind this round of grants.
Nine years ago, when they started the News Challenge, the goal was to develop new ideas to develop digital initiatives to deliver news to communities. When Alberto was asked, "What might we fund?" he resisted a definition of what exactly they would fund. Instead, Knight has used their funds to discover ideas from smart people working on these questions. Instead of prescribing what people should do. "My name is Knight Foundation and we don't know what we're doing" is the essential stance in this work.
The Challenge has moved from topic to topic. The subject of a free and universal web has hardly been exhausted with one attempt. Possibly there will be a more focused repeat of this theme.
Right now, Alberto tells us, the FCC is considering rule-making that could tier the internet. The debate is on about whether their actions could be anti-democratic, if the Internet is the public square or not. If you're rich and connected, you're ok. If you're on your own, you may not. If you're an individual developer, you may not. Alberto tells us that it's important to foster engagement and build networks of emerging leaders on this issue, which fundamentally affects news dissemination. Many of our projects on digital news and the sharing of information with communities assumed the Internet to be cheap/free. It turns out that the Internet may not become free and open.
Alberto reads an extended passage from Larry Lessig's critique of "The Social Network" in The New Republic:
What is important in Zuckerberg’s story is not that he’s a boy genius. He plainly is, but many are. It’s not that he’s a socially clumsy (relative to the Harvard elite) boy genius. Every one of them is. And it’s not that he invented an amazing product through hard work and insight that millions love. The history of American entrepreneurism is just that history, told with different technologies at different times and places.
Instead, what’s important here is that Zuckerberg’s genius could be embraced by half-a-billion people within six years of its first being launched, without (and here is the critical bit) asking permission of anyone. The real story is not the invention. It is the platform that makes the invention sing. Zuckerberg didn’t invent that platform. He was a hacker (a term of praise) who built for it. And as much as Zuckerberg deserves endless respect from every decent soul for his success, the real hero in this story doesn’t even get a credit. It’s something Sorkin doesn’t even notice.
(Speaking about Nantucket Nectar ,Lessig writes ) At each step after the first, along the way to giving their customers what they wanted, the two Toms had to ask permission from someone. They needed permission from a manufacturer to get into his plant. Permission from a distributor to get into her network. And permission from stores to get before the customer. Each step between the idea and the customer was a slog. They made the slog, and succeeded. But many try to make that slog and fail. Sometimes for good reasons. Sometimes not.
Zuckerberg faced no such barrier. For less than $1,000, he could get his idea onto the Internet. He needed no permission from the network provider. He needed no clearance from Harvard to offer it to Harvard students. Neither with Yale, or Princeton, or Stanford. Nor with every other community he invited in. Because the platform of the Internet is open and free, or in the language of the day, because it is a “neutral network,” a billion Mark Zuckerbergs have the opportunity to invent for the platform. And though there are crucial partners who are essential to bring the product to market, the cost of proving viability on this platform has dropped dramatically.
The tragedy... of this film is that practically everyone watching it will miss this point. Practically everyone walking out will think they understand genius on the Internet. But almost none will have seen the real genius here. And that is tragedy because just at the moment when we celebrate the product of these two wonders—Zuckerberg and the Internet—working together, policymakers are conspiring ferociously with old world powers to remove the conditions for this success. As “network neutrality” gets bargained away—to add insult to injury, by an administration that was elected with the promise to defend it—the opportunities for the Zuckerbergs of tomorrow will shrink. And as they do, we will return more to the world where success depends upon permission. And privilege. And insiders. And where fewer turn their souls to inventing the next great idea.
As a long time advocate of first amendment freedoms, Alberto works for the right to speak because we're citizens, not because we're given permission to speak. The right to speak on the Internet needs to be a right, not something that we're given permission to work on.
As we go forward, Alberto asks for our advice: how do we design a challenge or a question that will help keep the internet free?
How do we do this work at scale? What tools do we build to help anyone use the internet securely. What do we need to build a stronger internet? This should matter to you. This has to matter to you. If you have an idea about this, please send him an emaill.
Alberto closes by urging us to learn about issues around the open internet, Opportunity for everyone’s voice to be heard on the FCC website. Do it, he says.
knight foundationcivic mediafree internetalberto ibarguenjohn bracken
