New Publication: Community Fiber in Washington, D.C., Seattle, and San Francisco

Executive SummaryThis report provides detailed accounts of planning carried out in
connection with community fiber networks in Washington, D.C., San
Francisco, CA, and Seattle, WA. It includes information about existing
fiber assets that the cities identified, funding mechanisms that were
considered, and roadblocks that were encountered. Our hope is that this
report will be helpful to other cities that are considering launching
fiber optic networks.Download the report at SSRNKey Findings

  • The cities profiled in this report have each approached the question of community fiber differently.
  • Washington, D.C. made concessions and arrangements that allowed it
    to build a robust public-safety-quality fiber network, but limitations
    on the use of that network have made it unavailable to residents and
    businesses. Additionally, prices charged non-profits for use of the
    network are currently too high to be competitive with incumbent
    products.
  • San Francisco has been highly innovative in expanding fiber to
    public housing, aggressively leasing dark fiber to community anchor
    institutions such as libraries and schools, and ensuring free public
    Wi-Fi, but has not yet cracked the nut of alternative community
    residential or business fiber access.
  • Seattle has had an extensive city fiber loop in place since 1986,
    but regulations limiting use of poles and approvals for cabinets have
    slowed the rollout of competitive last-mile service. Seattle’s recent
    negative experience with Gigabit Squared (which was unable to execute on
    its last-mile promises and subsequently vanished from the scene) casts a
    shadow. Seattle’s current mayor appears to be determined to ameliorate
    both the regulatory burdens and the information asymmetries that have
    dogged the city.

via Susan Crawford

Although everyone thinks of high-speed, high-capacity Internet access
as a “must have” — a utility — the entire highly-concentrated
information-transport industry in the US can set prices and determine
the quality of their services at will. With the exception of the 16M
households that will have access to (expensive) Verizon FiOS services —
and can choose between that service and cable — the rest of the country
has vanishingly few choices for high-capacity data transport. And
America does not have a plan for making an upgrade to fiber optic
connections to homes and businesses.AT&T, Verizon, and Comcast, who together account for about
two-thirds of the trillion dollar enterprise value of this sector, have
tremendous scale and scope. And they’re sensible. They’re not about to
engage in price wars or unnecessary upgrades. They’re private companies
whose perfectly lawful interests do not necessarily align with the
public interest in ubiquitous, world-leading, inexpensive,
high-capacity, wired transport of data.As a result, we spend a lot of time waiting around, even though we’re impatient Americans. (Nice video here: Living with Lag.)
And we pay a lot – when it comes to high-capacity connections, we pay
more per megabyte of data than people do in developed countries other
than Mexico, Chile, and Turkey. Most Americans don’t know how much
better our data-transport story could be — because they haven’t been to
the places around the world where cheap unlimited symmetric
communications capacity is taken for granted.This is a social issue that undermines everything we want to
accomplish as a country: response to climate change, better educational
outcomes, reduction of inequality, creation of new jobs, creation of
greater public trust…Here’s the good news: Many mayors in America are unwilling to settle
for this situation. They’re considering clearing the way for fiber
networks to be built by public or private entities that use city
conduit, pole access, and other assets. (There are already more than 400
communities across the country with their own networks serving local
businesses and/or residents.) See muninetworks.org for information.Mayors and citizens have a great deal to learn from the experiences
of other cities. Today, with many thanks to John Connolly, Melissa
Nally, Travis West, and the Roosevelt Institute, the Berkman Center is
putting out our new white paper about efforts in Washington, DC, San
Francisco, and Seattle to explore competitive fiber. As you’ll read, all
three cities are still in the exploration/planning stage, and they have
each learned different things along the way. This report adds to the
growing pile of case studies in this area (here), including our own report about Leverett MA.