The Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (MIC), along with existing mobile virtual network operators (MVNO) have expressed their concern towards the Big Three mobile operators for the high prices of their networks to the MVNOs.
At 900 yen (USD $8) a month, LTE is rapidly transforming into a cheap data transfer service in Japan. Japan’s three largest mobile operators have started to license bandwith on existing infrastructure to third party resellers but the Japanese government and resellers alike have expressed concern at the high cost of bandwidth interfering with competition and an open marketplace.
Softbank ranks as the most expensive licensing agency, followed by KDDI and NTT Docomo. In comparison to NTT Docomo’s wholesale price of 1,234,911 yen (USD $12,150) per month for 10 Mbps of bandwidth, Softbank charges third party operators nearly three times the price, while KDDI charges twice that of NTT Docomo. KDDI and Softbank plan to ramp up sales of their own services to MVNOs this spring.
NTT Docomo, although cheaper and more bandwidth friendly than its direct competitors, enforces limits on tethering and swapping of SIM cards in the handsets that it sells to its customers.
Currently, there have been no changes in MVNO market share (Approximately 4.4%) since December of 2013. MIC hopes that the increasing direct involvement will foster further competition in the mobile network market.
Last Word:
Spectrum allocation has been a major problem in Japanese telecommunications. The dominance of NTT, KDDI, and Softbank has been recognized as an ongoing issue expressed in the 2009 ACCJ Internet Economy White Paper. Although MIC has attempted to strike a balance between supporting smaller operators and refraining from interfering with the market, there has been no successful solution.
Despite proposals for spectrum auctions, as done in the US, India, and South Korea, the prevailing strength of the three largest mobile operators does not allow room for growth for smaller MVNOs. As expressed in the 2014 ACCJ Viewpoint on Efficient Use of Spectrum, the Japanese government must be aggressive in actively allocating spectrum allocation and utilization for market competition purposes. Removing the chokehold on access to data is fundamental for data transparency and ensuring net neutrality – MIC has to demonstrate its committment to ensuring fair access to the market as the Japanese Internet Economy grows.
Source: Nihon Keizai Shimbun (Japanese)
Image Source: Pixabay
