The Evolution of Governance Structure in Cryptocurrencies and the Emergence of Code-Based Arbitration in Bitcoin

This case study by Markus Oermann and Nils Töllner, Hans-Bredow-Institute, describes how Bitcoin, the open source cryptocurrency, revised its core code to accommodate a new feature called “multi-signature transactions,” and looks closely at the decision-making processes within this open source community.Abstract: This case study describes the process by which Bitcoin revised its core code to accommodate a new feature called “multi-signature transactions.” Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency, which was introduced in 2009 and has spread rapidly since then. It is based on open-source peer-to-peer software that that leverages a network of user accounts (wallets) set up on peripheral sites in which the units of account (Bitcoins) may be stored after they are produced and transmitted. It is a goal of cryptocurrencies in general to operate without a central agent, which makes it complicated to resolve disputes. To address this, Bitcoin added multi-signature transactions. This case study examines how that change was made. In particular the case study explores how an open source community is able to maintain a stable codebase that can serve as a basis for an entire form of currency, while still making necessary changes. The case shows that the decision-making processes regarding transformations of Bitcoin’s governance structure are not as transparent as one might expect given the cryptocurrency’s commitment to open source. However, major changes to the code are publicly discussed in the Bitcoin developers’ community and the authors could not identify a single case of a decision in which the core development team deviated from the consensus of the community.These case studies are part of a globally coordinated, independent academic research pilot project about multistakeholder governance groups by the Global Network of Internet & Society Research Centers (NoC). Facilitated by the Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard University, this study examines existing multistakeholder governance groups with the goal of informing the future evolution of the Internet governance ecosystem. Building upon the NETmundial Principles and Roadmap, it contributes to current policy debates at the international level, including the Internet Governance Forum, the NETmundial Initiative, and other organizations and efforts.