Broadcast Treaty- A Solution in Search of a Problem

Nehaa Chaudhari gave a talk (for about 10 minutes) at a Side Event organized by Knowledge Ecology International on December 11, 2014 during SCCR 29.
Rough unedited notes from the talk is given below:

Proponents say they need this treaty to prevent "signal piracy." But the treaty goes well beyond that by creating rights to control "fixations" of broadcasts that only apply after you've received and recorded a signalLet's say a broadcaster shows a public domain movie on their network. Currently, nobody can restrict your rights to use that film however you like — whether that's recording it to watch later, making a remix with it, or even broadcasting it over your own network or on your own website. That is, after all, the point of the public domain, and it's a very good thing.
A Broadcasting Treaty, though, would give broadcasters the power to restrict your use of those works — even if they have no copyright interest in the works at all.There are proposals to create rights for giant corporations that own "channels" of content, like HBO, ESPN, the Disney Channel, etc, and these new rights would divert revenue from copyright owners to distributors. Since the ownership of distribution of video is much more concentrated than is ownership of video content, this would have distributional impacts that are not well understood. Also, there is likely to be redistribution of incomes out of some countries to a handful of large content distributors, and the impact of this cross country redistribution is not well understood.Giving broadcasters an unprecedented set of legal privileges is a sure-fire way to damage speech and innovation on the global Internet. Granting broadcasters, cablecasters and webcasters exclusive rights to authorize retransmissions of broadcasts over the Internet will allow them to block competition and innovation by allowing them to control the types of devices that can receive transmissions, and it will create new liability risks for Internet intermediaries that retransmit information on the Internet. If "signal piracy" is the concern, then a narrow, signal-focused approach is what is needed, not a global replication of the existing copyright regime.Is it really creating a problem and then trying to find a solution for it? Existing provisions in Rome, WPPT, WCT, TRIPS.
Broadcasters make several arguments as to why they need protection. First, if an entity is retransmitting a broadcaster’s signal, the broadcaster wants to be able to sue that entity, rather than rely on all the copyright owners of the individual programs. For example, if a Canadian company in Windsor is retransmitting the various Law & Order series broadcast by the NBC affiliate in Detroit, the affiliate wants the ability to sue the Canadian company directly, rather than have to convince the copyright owner of Law & Order to sue the Canadian company. Indeed, the owner of Law & Order might not have an economic incentive to sue, since it has already been paid for broadcast rights in both Detroit and Windsor.
Second, the simultaneous fixation rule of U.S. copyright law, 17 U.S.C. § 411(b), does not exist in many countries. The U.S. Copyright Act provides that the transmission of a live event can receive copyright protection if it is fixed – recorded – at the same time that it is transmitted. Thus, Fox receives copyright protection for the live broadcast of American Idol because it simultaneously tapes the broadcast. But in countries without the simultaneous fixation rule, broadcasters cannot rely on copyright to protect broadcasts of live events.Broadcasters received this sort of protection under the Rome Convention, and they have provided no evidence that the Rome Convention is not working adequately, nor economic justification for extending the term of protection by 30 years.

For more details visit http://cis-india.org/accessibility/news/wipo-sccr-29-broadcast-treaty-a-solution-in-search-of-a-problem