Keeping Up and Keeping it Real: An Analysis of the Social Life of Civic Media

Talk by Eric Gordon (@ericbot) of Emerson's Engagement Lab and Rogelio Lopez (@Tochtli_exe) of USC Annenberg at the MIT Center for Civic Media.
This is a liveblog of a talk on November 6, 2014, recorded by Alexis, Ali, Adrienne, Catherine, Nathan, and Erhardt.

The context of the talk is the space of "civic tech." It's a field that has been defined by corporations and foundations. They have been seeking to put a lot of things into recognizable envelopes.
Mostly, civic tech is associated with government and government innovation. Increasingly, there’s an effort made by other organizations to use that term. Some of the narratives that pop up in civic tech are that of the smart city, entrepreneurship, and efficiency.
They were curious about how would you characterize civic tech through a metaphor in terms of the operations of your organization? "We're the NASA of non-profits." This is to say it is a scientific enterprise and also that there is a frontier out ahead. This was a very positive spin on the use of technology in nonprofit work.
When we talk about civic tech to NGOs the rhetoric isn’t as positive. “It’s a sourdough starter, you have to keep feeding it unless it dies,” or “deer in the headlights.”
Most of the time, the metaphors being used to describe the technologies of integration are filled with fear and anxiety.
“Everything keeps changing all the time,” Gordon says to express his frustration with the technology landscape. "Keeping it to the traditional, like, grassroots organizing tools of going out and having one-on-one conversations."
Themes of "Keeping up" and "keeping it real" kept coming up in their interviews. Rogelio explains that keeping up means staying current with technologies, but they wanted to focus on “keeping it real,” because many of these communities were focused on communities who worked in the grassroots activism space.
For many organizations, legitimation is based in the grassroots. The efficacy is judged based on how it affects residents. The reality is organizations are struggling with the normative maxim “keeping it real.” Eric notes that they are particularly interested in community organization and grassroot techniques.
There is a need to complicate discourse. “There is so much stuff going on in the course of using technology." 

As part of their study, they did participant observation for 9 months at a community development organization. They experimented with implementation of new tools with that organization.
They conducted 14 interviews within a single community organization, and an additional 14 interviews with organizations around the country. Their analysis was based on an inductive development of the codebook.
The main question driving their work: How do civic media (the function and representation of tools) impact how organizations conceive of themselves and their constituents?
They took a phenomenological approach in terms of theory. They really wanted to understand how people really perceived what they do.
They didn't want to know precisely what manifested itself in the physical world, but rather how people perceived what they did. The methodology is influenced by Alfred Schutz, citing The Structures of the Life-world.
Adaptive Structuration Theory is a way of understanding structures and actors within those structures. AST asks how the rules associate with particular technologies reinforce and in tension with organizational rules and structures. Technology has a particular logic to it and when it interacts with another structure like an organization its logic is tweaked through its interaction.
AST as a disciple or field is focused on organizational change. It’s main interest is on the organization’s life itself and how things change. Their departures from AST are an interest in the medium rather than the organization and how the organizational context responds to the medium. Moving away from structure and spirit (spirit being the spirit of object). Moving towards function (previously "structure") and representation (previously "spirit"). The spirit being the spirit of the thing or the law. "The collective meaning that a thing has when it enters into a system." They are really interested in representation and are trying to explore that more deeply through this project.
Function and representation are two binaries that they employ to understand the organization's life.
Function is how the technologies are designed and deployed to accomplish the things within organizations. Representation is the flip side. It creates the appearance of getting things done and factors into analyze the cultural meaning of a tool and includes the potentially contested meanings of technology that emerge in use.
For example, when an organization starts using Facebook, we ask what is the meaning associated with using Facebook interact with the identity of your organization and how does that play out when you engage in these things.
They moved away from AST’s meaning of spirit, and towards the function which provides a context for meaning.

Moving toward data and metrics as evaluative measures to study the value of work. Keeping up is the idea of reaching youth. There is a sense that youth are using new technology. Alongside the sentiment of keeping up is the idea of keeping it really: a tradition of grassroots activism, challenging the authority of government. These organizations are serving a need government does not. Will adopting technology sacrifice the legitimacy of grassroots. Will orgs. become more bureaucratic?
As part of “keeping up”, in terms of cultural representation of innovation, they expected to see "disruptive paradigms," that technology will completely reorient what is done in an organization. In most cases, this was not the case. Disrupting paradigms weren’t applicable when orgs had spent years with horizontal power structures.
They discussed innovation in organizations in terms of risk. Who can take risks? They noted that if organizations fail it can be a representational threat to their legitimacy.
Governments sometimes build structures within themselves that can fail, e.g. New Urban Mechanics and other government innovation offices. This doesn't have a corresponding structure within an NGO.
The idea of disruption was not really present when they discussed innovation, Gordon says.
”Keeping up” and “Keeping it Real” with Youth
What is the role of youth in these organizational innovations? Youth represents this aspect of keeping up. "Keeping up with youth" is one the main reasons why organizations think technology should be employed.
Youth are functionally the audience that many orgs want to reach. They represent a deep and future connection in the community. There is a function to them that is a means to an end. The youth represent a deep connection to the future. Whether or not this is accurate is another matter. They're not talking about the accuracy of these perceptions.
Youth were also really important with this idea of keeping it real. Youth encapsulate obsolescence. Youth don’t need organizations. There's a possibility that they'll stop connecting with the org. This is part of the tension around keeping it real. The youth symbolize the future, but also a possible future without the org.
"The youth stretch the limits of authenticity," they say."Youth are great but the way they communicate is not authentic."
Grassroots
Youth have always been a central target of grassroots organizing. People see them as ambassadors for new technology.
For many organizations that they interviewed they found that “grassroots” approach became a common lens as to how they view technology in terms of function and representation.
Youth became the dominate lens for representing new technology. For a variety of reasons, often systemic, communities weren’t being heard or served. Grassroots organizing has been a means to circumventing these ends. This has worked for many communities, notably immigrant groups. The history of community organizing in this particular organization weren’t around being more inclusive or horizontal, but how to help implement technology to aid in these initiatives.
The definition of the grassroots is, “Its not like we can do this and so we don’t have to do grassroots anymore …”
Another metaphor they wanted to tease out was the metaphor of paper. Statements like “We use a LOT of paper” highlight this frame.
What’s important about these statements is that “paper” became a theme that’s much more powerful than anything that could happen online.
The way that played out was through amplification and transformation. Meaning making versus facilitating meaning exchange.
Amplification
Amplification is the use of ICTs to amplify an existing message generated by the organization. Amplification is often centralized through a communication specialist. Though the person still existed, the duties were more distributed. “I think the goal of technology and social media would be to transmit important knowledge to the household and to the parents.”
Transformation
Transformation is the use of ICTs to transform messages through dialogue and co-creation. We’re trying to figure out how we can use the technology to enhance the kind of work we can do. There’s a sense of trying to stick their neck out to use tech in new ways. Burdened with this tension of function and representation.
Both of these strategies - Amplification and Transformation - were burdened with this tension between function and representation.
Challenges
In doing this work, they came across some challenges. Its very possible that people felt compelled to embellish fears. If they talked up what they did, researchers might have been disappointed. They started in the interventionist modality. We went to an organization to co-design some tools, but as we played that approach out, some other factors became more interesting. Started by how to evaluate multiple tools in a single space. DId not acknowledge representation, were only focused on function. Not evaluating that larger construct they realized was wrong.
From "civic tech" to "civic media"
Civic tech may not be the most productive term for understanding the phenomenology; rather civic media would be a more accurate term for. Civic tech is more focused on tools, but situated tools are always complex. So understanding impact must be taken in the understanding of context.
Civic media addresses the tool as medium, an object in the world that mediates function and representation (always together) - where the meaning of the technology and its impact is always a coupling between actual outcomes and the presentation of those outcomes.
Their greater insight was the need to understand the design process in terms of function and representation. People do not use tools only for their function. And we should not be making tools simply for their function.
Conclusions
We need to tease out face-to-face and mediated practices. They are richly textured and shouldn’t be mistaken for a binary.
Core conclusions:

  • Civic media are challenging organizational identities more than they are challenging the organizational processes.
  • Civic tech has been driven by function, but function doesn't drive the implementation of tools.
  • Civic media suggests a methodological approach to tools.

Question & Answer
Ethan asks about how they, as interviewers, encounter organizational anxieties as part of the interview process. Can you talk about how these fears are inherent in the tech, or whether conversations about tech simply surface existing anxieties?
Eric notes thatYou are right to point out that these anxieties may come from the way that technology represents change, and potentially risk to people's jobs. Specifically, within grassroots organizations (someone else will have to keep typing)
Rogelio notes that civic tech is sometimes perceived as a barrier to the relationship building that the community org already does.
Q: How did they define authenticity? What was it they were so anxious about?
Eric: Authenticity was about face-to-face in relationships. All of the physicality was authentic. It’s not really that surprising, but was surprising how prominent that was and how co-present the idea of excitement and potential of using a new tool was with “but maybe we won’t have the same face-to-face relationship with youth that we once had?” Is that one of the costs?
Ethan: Can you expand on the idea of youth being inauthentic?
Eric: Everyone spoke highly of working with youth but cautiously about how they communicate. I don't think we spoke to anyone that said the rhetoric around youth was dangerous. It was always positive.
Two themes: (1) Maybe youth won't need us and (2) They arrange things between each other with text and they don't talk. They represent hope, the future, but also fear of getting there, where we’re no longer talking to each other.
Rogelio: We found that there were degrees to youth involvement and decision-making across orgs. And this affects their role in media-making. In my experience, the youth were placed in a position in the org where they could take on the risk of doing new things usually technology without disrupting the core functioning of the organization.
Yu: Sometimes I’m a little skeptical, my question is whether the mission of the organization mattered. If it's a domestic violence organization would the same forces apply as other kinds of grassroots organizations?
Eric: We looked specifically at organizations that are geographically focused, doing grassroots work. And the specificity of the mission of the organizations we talked to mattered quite a bit.
Yu: Another question, how do we define civic tech? Do things like donor management systems count?
Eric: I purposefully didn't try to define civic tech because it's broad. For example the recent Knight report includes Uber as a civic technology. It's been government focused but impacts other orgs both informal and formal. We wanted to see where the term expands beyond the government context. Would be worth doing a similar study in government innovation offices.
Ali: Representation could be constrained by form and function. Are they inextricably related?
Eric: Yes. They have to be. The way an org adopts a technology is always determined by the function of that tool and the way they want it to function within a particular role. The spirit of a technology changes as it gets used. We are interested in how representations change over time. The organization that we worked more with (the NASA org) was very sophisticated in how they used technology and were also factoring in audience when they made decisions about what to use and how. In looking at this area, we are always keeping form and function together as a coupling.
Nathan: Curious as to how what you found out will influence what you make.
Eric: It's something I struggle with as a scholar and practitioner and "aspiring non-hypocrite." What is the scholarly approach? And what is the practitioner approach? Does anyone want to work with the scholar that wants to get things done? I think it's an important thing to deal with. Building the capacity of organizations to deal with those kinds of researchers is probably part of it.
Rahul: AST framework , did you find organizations that created technologies and could be characterized as "digital native"?
Eric: We did talk to those. But the numbers were so small, it's hard to identify patterns.
Rogelio: The org we did the deep dive with was a pre-internet organization, and frame themselves that way. At the same time, there are digital natives in this organization. Of course, we need to be careful about making statements like that as the technology proficiency falls along a spectrum. Pushing back from a grassroots perspective on what the technology could do. But there was a feeling that this is the new norm.
Chelsea: You talked about power of representational force? Where is that coming from? Is it coming from funders that want to see that play out in projects they invest, is it coming from youth in the community, etc.?
Eric Gordon: The meaning making framework is our point of phenomenological observation. What we were able to look at was not the source but the meaning making. Getting to sources is tough. Some of it was coming from funders. And some of that gets to functionality. Some orgs actually presented themselves as not keeping up. If they don't keep up, funders won't fund them. We have to see these things within this context, larger reputation issues at stake.
Chelsea: Maybe some of that comes from signalling from your peer organizations. When it becomes digitized it becomes so much more visible. So some tools might have this ability to capture a moment that can be share more broadly. Digital has a representational value as well.
Felipe, Berkman Center: Expand bit more on “keeping it real”? From my experience on working on civic technologies, I found that we were afraid that our tools were somewhat severed from real social world.
Rogelio: I want to pull out an example from an interview, one of the biggest struggles in implementation was putting it in a language that was understandable. THe fear was that the form of the organization would become too abstract for and possibly unintelligible to the people that it serves. This was about trying to meet people on their own terms in the lived politics of people. This is why we wanted to bring in the grassroots as mediator of technology and how its used.
Ethan: Something interesting here is the about being passionate about "grassroots" as an end-run around bureaucracy and avoiding the government tech systems. There is so much difference in how reaching online is seen as compared to perception of grassroots penetration.
Eric: In the civic tech space in particularly, I like to use the example of Jen Pahlka mentioning an opossum reported in the Boston's Citizen Connect tool. A neighbor took car of the opossum without the government needing to intervene. This was an example used to show how civic tech can be used to solve problems without government.
Community organizations were initially created for just this purpose. And now we have these technologies described as doing that kind of work. Do the technologies become a threat to the raison d'etre of the organization?
The effort that is perceived in signing an online petition is seen compared with signing an actual petition.
Ethan: You have given me an idea of an experiment. We take 10,000 opossums and 10,000 trash cans and distribute them randomly across the United States. Is there a correlation with the rise of civic tech and citizens solving their opossum problems?
Mine Gencel Bak: In terms of impact, how do you evaluate it?
Eric: This has motivated me to look into this and build some operationalizable tools for evaluation.
engagement laberic gordonrogelio lopezcivic techyouthCivic media