Japan is revising its privacy framework, the first such update in over a decade. The revisions are being driven by the enormous advances in technology during the period since the law was first introduced and concerns that ambiguities in the law and inconsistency in enforcement are discouraging business innovation in utilizing personal information and “big data.” Parallel to this are voices from civil society and “users” raising issue with how personal data is protected in this new environment and statements from key business organizations that updating the law, including the creating of a central “accountable” authority, is vital to safeguarding Japanese firms operating under different national privacy regimes abroad.
The Japanese government established a Personal Data Review Working Group in September of 2013 and has held to date nine public sessions of the group with the goal of releasing an outline for possible new legislation in mid-June for public comment. Keio University Professor Fumio Shimpo, an expert in privacy matters, is a member of the working group. Given the complexity of the issues being discussed within the Working Group, there are continuing concerns about the compressed timetable for discussion and public comment and issues with the transparency and inclusivity of the work of the working group.
For these reasons, KIPIS sponsored in collaboration with the American Chamber of Commerce in Japan (ACCJ) two forums on March 10 and May 13 bringing together experts on privacy from government, the private sector and academia to engage a wide range of multistakeholder representatives. The purpose was to expand the circle of discussion on the new legislation and to prepare the ground for the scheduled public comment period in July. A common concern emerging from both sessions was worries that the proposals under discussion did not reflect adequately the real world experience of the business community nor that of users. Instead, the revisions appear to be largely driven by administrative perspectives and the jurisdictional concerns of the different ministries involved, particularly involving the authorities and resources to be given a new “third party organization,” which will “coordinate” privacy policy from the Cabinet Office.
The May 13 conference was divided into two segments, including presentations from an expert panel and an hour long session featuring statements and questions from the multistakeholder community.
Keynote remarks were given by the Keio University Dean of the Faculty of Information Studies and the Environment, Jun Murai. Dean Murai is a member of the IT Strategy HQ advisory committee that provides expert input to the government on IT policy developments in Japan. He stressed the critical nature of the current reform and the need for broad discussion and a transparent decision making process.
Yoshihiro Sato, the chief privacy officer with Hewlett Packard and a member of the personal data working group, led off the panel discussion by outlining the state of the play in the working group. He underlined concerns shared by many in the business community that there is a mistaken tendency in Japan to see privacy as a “legal” issue rather than as an “economic” problem. Sato pointed out that the largest deficiency of the current privacy framework is the preoccupation with prejudging new business models based on past interpretations of the law rather than analyzing the real risk of infringement of individual privacy, which is often quite small. He said that this administrative mind-set and lack of flexibility is hurting innovation in Japan.
Sato’s comments were largely reinforced by panel members, Ryuji Tsutsui from Sony, Makoto Yokozawa from the Nomura Research Institute and Hiroyoshi Watanabe from the ACCJ, who stressed that the revision of the law should be seen as an opportunity to strike a better balance between protection of data and utilization of data. Yokozawa also expressed concern that the working group is not giving adequate consideration to experiences with regulating privacy in other jurisdictions. He noted that progress on developing new privacy frameworks is behind schedule in the US and the EU – and said that despite the urgency of the issue it may not be desirable for Japan to get too far ahead of these other advanced economies. He added that the multistakeholder model and the use of “trusted” third parties is important to effective governance in the privacy area — if the government seeks to unilaterally define privacy policy, it threatens innovation. Watanabe also stressed this point, noting the relationship between flexibility and innovation on the Internet.
Mari Matthews, the head of government relations for MetLife Alico, noted a worry that is widespread in the financial services community about the possibility of the creation of a duplicative regulatory framework, if the mission and authorities of a new “third party authority” are not well coordinated with the existing responsibilities of the Financial Supervisory Agency (FSA) that currently oversees cross-border data transfers in the financial sector. She said that the goal should be to minimize limitations on cross-border transfers not to create a separate administrative framework. Keio Professor Jun Takei added to this discussion by observing that rules and regulations on data transfers needed to be clear and not take the form of “punishments.”
Izumi Aizu, the executive director of the Institute for a HyperNetwork Society, facilitated the multistakeholder portion of the program. He said that apart from the specifics of any new privacy law attention also needs to be given as how to reflect input from the multistakeholder community into the interpretation and administration of the law. Privacy protection and promoting the utilization of data was the job of the whole Internet community not just governments.
Communications policy expert Koichiro Fujii agreed, saying that there needs to be a process not just for interpreting the law but for evaluating risk. The current administration of privacy in Japan, he said is too “paternalistic” and overly restrictive. Attorney Yoichi Itakura agreed, explaining that Japan need to create a culture of “accountability” – so that people can try new models, with the understanding that they need to take responsibility for their actions. This approach was also echoed by Intellectual Ventures CEO Masanobu Katoh, who said that the business community wants less not more regulation and that the key is creating a framework for privacy that allows for “use” of data.
Commenting from the user perspective, Kansei Gakuin Professor Akiko Orita observed that knowledge about the Internet among users is surprisingly low. She said that privacy is best protected by a simple, widely understood set of principles. Keio University graduate student Keisuke Otsubo made a similar observation, noting that his classmates are the larger users of social media, but still quite unsophisticated in how to manage their own privacy.
Opinions regarding the role of the multistakeholder community in the process were mixed. Michiyo Sasaki, a woman business executive wondered if the community is well enough organized and defined in Japan to participate effectively. Attorney Naoko Mizukoshi agreed, but felt that there needed to be some “process” for involving the community in decision on privacy and other concerns that are so important to the future of the Internet. Building on his opening remarks, multistakeholder group facilitator Izumi Aizu said that one option might be to explore ways to create a multistakeholder advisory track to provide input to and possibly oversee the activities of “third party authority.”
KIPIS plans to convene a third forum following the release of the proposal from the Personal Data Review Working Group in July. The decisions that Japan makes are being closely watched in Asia, given the size of its economy, the important role of its companies and financial institutions in the region and Japan’s announced interest in joining the APEC Cross Border Privacy Regime. The new framework for privacy being developed in Japan could also influence the current transatlantic debate over privacy between the US and the EU over the role of government in regulating privacy and the extent to which key decisions and sanctions should be left to market forces.
