On May 20th, The Keio International Project for the Internet & Society (KIPIS), along with the International University Center for Global Communications (GLOCOM) and Japan Network Information Center (JPNIC), organized a panel to reflect on the results from the conference.
The NETmundial “Global Multistakeholder Meeting on the Future of the Internet Governance” held April 23-24 in São Paulo, Brazil, was an important milestone. Before the conference, an open call for online contributions from different stakeholders spanning all major continents. The report drafted based upon these contributions served as the foundation for the NETmundial Outcome Document. This draft was then discussed among 1,480 stakeholders from 97 different countries representing their stake in the Internet ecosystem.
NETmundial demonstrated that Internet governance is an issue shared globally and willhopefully serve as a catalyst for further global Internet discussion on the issues highlighted in the NETmundial Multistakeholder Statement.
Three NETmundial participants from Japan: Adam Peake from GLOCOM, Akinori Maemura from JPNIC, and Shuji Yamaguchi from the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communication (MIC) were joined on a panel with Masanobu Kato, Vice-Chair of IGF-Japan, and Yu-Chuang Kuek, ICANN Vice President and Managing Director for Asia.The panel was moderated by KIPIS Director, Jim Foster.
Akinori Maemura discussed his presentation to the conference with a brief history of Internetgovernance. In 2013, when Edward Snowden leaked information regarding the NSA’s PRISM Project conducted by the US Government, Internet governance issues quickly rose to become a top priority for many countries and people around the world. The Brazilian government and representatives of various global civil society organizations organized NETmundial to set principles and develop a roadmap for Internet governance.
Adam Peake, who was a member of the drafting committee for the NETmunidal statement, reflected on the process through which the statement was drafted. Comments were received from around the world and these were carefully reviewed and incorporated by the drafting committee The process, although rushed, provided equal opportunity with all stakeholders of all nations, creating a truly multistakeholder process.
Possibly the biggest weakness of the multistakeholder approach is the time required to build consensus. Never, especially on such a large scale and with such important issues at stake are there unanimous agreements. MIC’s Yamaguchi analyzed the reactions of nations such as Russia, that maintained its opposition to statement until the very end. These reasons became apparent later as Russia announced its intention to further restrict Internet access domestically, social networking.
The NETmundial conference, despite considerations for a follow-up event, is likely a one-time event. Kato spoke on how the NETmundial results highlight the importance of like-minded meetings, such as the upcoming Asia-Pacific Regional Internet Governance Forum (APr IGF) in India and other IGF meetings. Unlike the NETmundial, IGF has not to date produced statements or decisions. This is an important difference and there remains the question of how the results from NETmundial are to be followed up.
Yu-Chuang Kuek, who joined by video, encouraged the audience with positive comments about the role of Japan in supporting Internet governance. Kuek called on Japan to set an example for Asia by developing pragmatic solutions to further foster the multistakeholder model.
Common to these presentations was a sense of concern about the future of the Internet absent greater attention to issues of Internet governance. However, while the Internet plays a major role in the Japanese economy, society, and government, government policy on the Internet both domestically and internationally has lagged behind. Audience questions to the panelists raised this concern more pointedly as individuals commented that engineers and entrepreneurs alike are “quietly worried” about what impediments governments may enact upon the Internet economy and innovation through poorly designed policy in Japan and Asia at large.
NETmundial made significant progress in defining the principles and setting the roadmap for Internet governance. The next step is implementation. As KIPIS Director Foster concluded, the next topic for discussion must be how Japan will develop the multistakeholder model domestically.
KIPIS is now working with GLOCOM and the Institute for HyperNetwork Society (Tama University) to identify the institutional and procedural changes needed to create greater multistakeholder involvement in Internet governance in Japan, and aims to release a draft working document outlining its proposals for government and private sector alike in summer 2014.
