Kids' internet use more private than ever: as risks change, so must parenting

EU Kids Online's interactive Final Report "EU Kids Online – Findings, Methods, Recommendations" sums up the combined results and recommendations regarding children and online risk based in the work of over 150 researchers from 33 countries. Since 2006 the EU Kids Online network has researched children’s online risks and opportunities. The Hans-Bredow-Institut, partner for Germany from the begiing, is coordinating the project from now on.During the course of the third phase of the project, from 2011 till 2014, children’s online user patterns have changed considerably and they are now using the internet in more places in their daily lives.In particular new internet-enabled devices are making children’s usage more private than ever. At the same time, compared with 2010, European 11- to 16-year-olds are now more likely to b exposed to hate messages (from 13% to 20%), pro-anorexia sites (9% to 13%), self-harm sites (7% to 11%) and cyberbullying (7% to 12%).

The project also found how Europeans are different from each other. For children and online risk, cross-national differences are greatest in the incidence of sexual content risks. Children who are bullied or who give away personal data are evenly distributed across Europe.Evidence based policyOne of the key goals of the project has been to ensure an active dialogue with stakeholders to ensure policy has a robust evidence base. Questions on children and media tend to provoke strong fears and feelings. As researchers we try to get a clear picture of what children actually do, feel and what is harmful for them in order to inform policy and prescriptive measures. The success has been eminent:European Commission Vice President and Commissioner for Digital Agenda, Neelie Kroes stated: 'EU Kids Online has been hugely important for European stakeholders as the key provider of trusted evidence to help us make the internet a better place for kids.'As for worried parents, Prof. Dr. Uwe Hasebrink, director of the Hans-Bredow-Institut, adds: 'Our best advice to parents is for them to:

  • Support children’s exploration of the internet from an early age and inform themselves about the benefits and the risks that the internet offers;
  • Focus on enhancing children’s opportunities, coping skills and resilience to potential harm;
  • Think less about risk and focus instead on engaging, fun activities and positive content;
  • Communicate regularly with children about what they may find problematic online;
  • Be clear about expectations and rules relating to online behaviour; 

10 key findings from the project

  • 1.    The more children use the internet, the more digital skills they gain, and the higher they climb the ‘ladder of online opportunities’ to gain the benefits.
  • 2.    Not all internet use results in benefits: the chance of a child gaining the benefits depends on their age, gender and socio-economic status, on how their parents support them, and on the positive content available to them.
  • 3.    Children’s use, skills and opportunities are also linked to online risks; the more of these, the more risk of harm; thus as internet use increases, ever greater efforts are needed to prevent risk also increasing.
  • 4.    Not all risk results in harm: the chance of a child being upset or harmed by online experiences depends partly on their age, gender and socio-economic status, and also on their resilience and resources to cope with what happens on the internet.
  • 5.    Also important is the role played by parents, school and peers, and on national provision for regulation, content provision, cultural values and the education system.
  • 6.    Pornography tops children’s online concerns.
  • 7.    Violent, aggressive, cruel or gory content came a close second - although violence receives less public attention than sexual material.
  • 8.    What particularly upsets them is real (or realistic) rather than fictional violence, and violence against the vulnerable such as children or animals.
  • 9.    Children’s concern about online risks rises markedly from nine to 12 years old. Younger children are more concerned about content risks, and as they get older they become more concerned about conduct and contact risks.
  • 10.    Children see video-sharing websites as most linked with violent, pornographic and other content risks.

Information about the survey

Information about the project

  • The EU Kids Online project (2011-2014) aimed to enhance knowledge of European children’s and parents’ experiences and practices regarding risky and safer use of the internet and new online technologies, and thereby to inform the promotion of a safer online environment for children. The project was funded by the EC Safer Internet Programme (SI-2010-TN-4201001).
  • Countries included in the project were: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey and UK. In addition the project has cooperated with researchers from Australia, Brazil and the USA.
  • EU Kids Online conducted a face-to-face, in home survey of 25,000 9-16 year old internet users and their parents in 25 countries, using a stratified random sample and self-completion methods for sensitive questions.
  • Our recent research findings, methods and recommendations include updating and analysis of our 25 country survey, in-depth interviews with 9- to 16- year olds in nine countries, expansion of the open access, searchable European evidence database, and a research toolkit of our methods to guide researchers and research users.

Using measures of online activities, risk of harm and parental mediation, we identified four country clusters that form Europe in the field of children and online risk .

  • Supported risky explorers (Denmark, Finland, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden)This cluster has more children who are experienced social networkers. They encounter more sexual risks online and their more parents are actively involved in guiding their children’s internet use.Parental mediation might co-evolve with risk and opportunity taking by children: as children gain more experience and encounter more risks, parents engage more actively in safeguarding their internet use. There is, however, a relatively small group of vulnerable children in these countries that experience similar levels of risk to their peers but lack the parental mediation and opportunities also enjoyed by their peers.Policy makers should therefore support parents and schools, and stimulate industry players to enhance responsible practices in relation to internet safety, including seeking to reach and support those few vulnerable children may ‘get lost’ in an environment full of experts.
  • Semi-supported risky gamers (Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Estonia, Poland and Romania)In these countries, children encounter only moderate online opportunities, mainly focused on entertainment, and games in particular. Yet they still experience relatively high levels of risk and harm: some encounter a specific risk, others a range of risks.Parents undertake rather diverse types of mediation in these countries, including active and restrictive forms of mediation, although it seems these are relatively ineffective. This may be because the online opportunities and associated digital skills have only emerged relatively recently in these countries, so supportive structures and good practice are not yet established.Although parents seem to be trying strategies across the board, further investigation is needed to understand why levels of risk are relatively high and what further interventions would be beneficial to encourage opportunities and reduce harm.
  • Protected by restrictions (Belgium, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Turkey and the UK)Children’s online experiences in this cluster of countries is characterised by relatively low levels of risk probably because internet use is also more limited and largely restricted to practical activities. While parents might be glad that their restrictive mediation practices prevent risk, it does seem that they may miss out on many of the online opportunities.The question for policy makers, parents and educators in these countries is whether opportunity uptake can be increased while simultaneously limiting more extensive risk of harm. It is possible that this could be achieved by a move away from more restrictive forms of mediation towards more active mediation patterns.Such an approach would have to acknowledge that risk will thereby result, and further investigation is needed to see whether children can become sufficiently resilient to cope with risk when they encounter it.
  • Unprotected networkers (Austria, Hungary, Lithuania and Slovenia)Finally, there is a cluster of countries where children’s experiences are fairly narrow but potentially problematic: the social aspects of Web 2.0 seem to have been taken up with gusto and the children subsequently encounter risks but not as much harm, from being in contact with these opportunities.Here the challenge is that parents are not as involved in their children’s internet use as in the supported risky explorers cluster that they otherwise resemble, probably because, as with the semi-supported risky gamers, the internet is a relatively recent addition in many families, especially for the parents.Treat media coverage concerning online risks critically