Anthea Watson Strong is a community organizer and leader on the Google civic engagement team. This is the first of two talks on what is the civic tech ecosystem, where do we fit and how do we grow it?
How can we do a better job of designing civic engagement tools? Two points:
- People still need to make dinner. People are rational. They have a lot of things going on in their lives. We need to make a good case that our tools matter to their everyday lives.
- The Internet is not magic.
We need to do a better job being honest about how people spend their time. She's going to lay out a framework to help us understand which tools can have impact in the world.
She describes her past as a community organizer in Milwaukee. It was a hard job. Trying to convince people to spend their time working on civic issues and take time away from their kids, taking care of their parents or whatever is a hard sell.
2013 Pew survey shows that in the past 2 months, 22% had attended a meeting. 18% had contacted representatives. In CA, 13.5% of eligible voters turned out to vote. Anthea thinks we can do better.
The Calculus of Voting paper tries to use game theory to explain why people vote. The equation is P * B + D > C.
P = Probability that your action will affect the decision
B = Benefit to you of the changed outcome
D = Sense of civic duty the user gets from the outcome - the sense you get when you are part of something bigger than youself
C = cost of the civic action
In the 2012 election, the likelihood of your vote changing the election is 0. P * B is 0. People vote because of D outweighed the cost of voting. At the local level this changes a little. Say you want a dog park, you have to drive to a meeting, do some public speaking. The cost is high. But the P is high, too. Your argument might have a real impact.
Back to the Internet not being magic. Sometimes we assume that because we are in the Internet age the old rules don't apply. It's hard to get people to pay attention. We have three levers:
- Cost
- Duty
- Probability
So we can lower the cost of taking civic action - by making it easier, for example the Voting Information Project built by Google. Google also builds voting portals around the world, for example in India.
The Duty lever is around increasing the positive feelings of being engaged. Campaigns are good at this - creating content that moves people to action.
The Probability lever seems like one we wouldn't be able to move much at the federal level. However the Internet actually changes this a little. Groups need to work in tandem. Can we help our users find each other online and organize together? If a user can get other users to take action we can measure that and show that they are having impact.
Too often in this room I see tools that are designed for ideal user behavior instead of real user behavior. It's great to show people nuances of policy but they still have dinner to make. Technologists - how can we reduce the cost of civic action and increase the probability of change? This is personalization. How come I can't get a push notification about a civic issue that I care about right now related to my geolocation and my interests? [Live Blogger note: Erhardt Graeff is inventing this technology right now at the Center for Civic Media. It's called ActionPath. ] We need to work at local, state levels as well as federal. Academics - What are the civic actions that are most impactful? Let's evaluate best practices. We can do better.
