He decided to talk about the 3rd of July. What happened then? It was the day between the signing of the Declaration of Independence and the 4th of July. John Adams wrote a letter to Abigail to recall the event that had started everything that led to the American Revolution. He traced the initial event to a specific place - the State House in Boston in 1771. A case argued there let the British go from house to house without any probable cause. This infringed peoples basic liberties. John Adams was in the audience and throughout his life it was that case, that courtroom, that day that set this country on a course for independence.
13 years after that Declaration at the Wall Street and Nassau Street intersection in NYC, this dream became a reality. It was the first capital where the first Congress met. It was 225 years ago this Sunday that John Adams stood up and introduced the Bill of Rights. When people questioned why they needed such a thing he talked about the courthouse in 1771 in Boston.
The Bill of Rights and the Fourth Amendment provides the fundamental protection against unlawful search and seizure.
The Fourth Amendment persevered from mail through telegraph through telephone. Our fundamental question is how it will continue to flourish. There have always been people like you in the room. When the pendulum swings there are always people who can swing it back.
The last year has been amazing. As a company we joined many others to increase encryption, transparency, and contractual protections. But there is only so much we can do by ourselves. We need government reform. We have taken steps to shiedl foreign data from foreign governments. But we need government reform here.
We need to continue to put an end to bulk data collection. We need to improve transparency. Microsoft sued the government last year. We won certain rights but there is more that needs to be done. We need to reform the secret court. Even when you get to the courtroom you don't necessarily have the information
In Foley Square in Manhattan, it is the US Court building that will decide the next step in the Fourth Amendment. Microsoft has sued the government a second time. The government is seeking all the Outlook content of a customer of ours. This warrant would make the British blush. Because it tells Microsoft to go from building to building throughout the Cloud, over 100 facilities, go where we must, in order to find and turnover the info the government seeks. It's the broadest possible warrant one can imagine in the 21st century. It overturns the fundamental protections of the Fourth Amendment. In this instance, the building where the data is is just outside of Dublin in Ireland. So the US government is asserting that US companies must get data from foreign countries. Ireland is not Iran. It is a democracy. The US has a treaty with the Irish. They need to use the treaty to get the data.
We live in a world where people need to get along and people have fundamental freedoms that need to be preserved. We need to live in a world where governments respect international borders and live up to their treaties. And they need to live up to the principles that got us started here in the first place.
It's fundamentally about technology. The important thing about tech is that it's a tool. Engineers do what they do because they know what it can do for others. Tech needs to serve people. Government that is an institution that is founded to serve people. We need to continue to ensure that technology and government come together in a way that serves people.
Q & A between Andrew and Brad Smith:
A: What do you think caused this massive imbalance? Was it 9/11 or was it the development of the technology? Is it the fear of what happened or fear of technology?
B: Clearly it was a response to 9/11. This has happened historically. But it was not a lack of understanding of what technology can do but an appreciation of what it can do. Early technology and spying was fundamental to countries winning wars. They see it as part of their arsenal.
A: If Congress doesn't understand how the Internet works. And people don't read Terms of Service agreements. And then the judicial system has people that were trained long before Internet. How can we debate these issues in a fair way?
B: It helps if people can understand the technology better. The understanding of tech in Congress has risen rapidly over the past decade. But there's something more that's a debate between fundamental values - security/safety and personal liberty. The balance has gone too far for what is a sustainable approach. This is a moment where we need to stand up and explain that it's not right to collect emails just because you can.
Q from audience: Corporations don't respect borders. Why should government?
B: Corporations do respect borders. We are bound by local law. There is asymmetry in the sense that we have more mobility than nations.
Q from audience: Given private sector's role in colelcting information, does the term 'Big Brother' need to be redefined?
B: These questions that are being asked about government should be asked about corporations. Both are collecting large amounts of data. People should be asking for transparency of information. How do we ensure that citizens and communities have control over what is collected and how it's used? How do we ensure that there is accountability?
Q from audience: What was it like negotiating with the USA or with Google? Is there a difference?
B: When you have a negotiation with a large group, the hardest thing for an institution is to know what it wants. I enjoyed working with the folks at Google. We were able to decide what we wanted. The hardest thing from the US side was the number of voices in the government which made it hard to make up its mind.
Q from audience: Historically Microsoft hasn't been great at the consumer perspective, why should we trust you now?
B: Judge us by what we do. Push us to be transparent. Push the whole industry and government to be transparent. Then you can judge us by our deeds. When it comes to tech, we are rolling out encryption. We put in our contracts to enterprise customers that if the government seeks their data we will litigate instead of handing it over. We have not lost a case yet. If they request data in foreign data centers we will litigate. That's why we are going to Foley Square.
Q from audience: We keep cutting government. How can we make the case for austerity when it might harm democracy?
B: I don't think we should be making a case for austerity. As a corporation we have made the case for education, technology education and research. As a company, we have a perspective that infrastructure, education and freedoms are important to basic freedoms and to innovation.
A: The Digital Divide continues to exist. If we are going to create a 21st Century educational system, how can we do so with a poor infrastructure and high cost?
B: We need to bring broadband to everyone.
A: If you had one message to this community for where they should be going, what would you say?
B: Civic innovation is a priority from the top of the company. We would love to partner with you all and be part of what you are doing. But push us for transparency, don't be polite. Be direct. We want to listen.
